(These awards were last presented in 2009.)

2009
Twyla Blackbird, Central Junior High, Cheerleading
Brandon Mellen, South Junior High, Track
Steve Heffernan, Free State High, Cross Country & Track
Brian "Chip" Anderson, Lawrence High, Cross Country

2008
Angela May, Southwest Junior High, Girls' Basketball
Kyle Stucky, South Junior High, Track
Jon Renberger, Free State High, Tennis
Brad Stoll, Lawrence High, Baseball

2007
Jacob Larsen, Central Junior High, Girls' Basketball
David Schneider, Southwest Junior High, Boys' Basketball
Kristin Mallory, Lawrence High, Girls' Basketball
Chuck Law, Free State High, Boys' Basketball

2006
Kathy Stuntz, South Junior High, Volleyball
Mike Ofer, West Junior High, Basketball
Bryan Duncan, Free State High, Girls' Basketball
Brian "Chip" Anderson, Lawrence High, Cross Country & Track

2005
Michelle Karleskint, Southwest Junior High, Girls’ Basketball
Jim Siebert, West Junior High, Wrestling
Kathy Johnson, Lawrence High & Free State High, Girls' Gymnastics
Scott Stidham, Lawrence High, Football & Track

2004
Scott Forkenbrock, Central Junior High, Girls’ Track
Patrick Naughton, South Junior High, Wrestling
Jama Crady, Free State High, Girls’ Swimming & Diving
Annette McDonald, Free State High, Boys' Swimming & Diving
David Platt, Lawrence High, Boys' Basketball

2003
Julie Miller, West Junior High, Volleyball
Mike Lewis, Southwest Junior High, Boys’ Basketball, Track & Girls’ Golf
Steve Heffernan, Free State High, Cross Country & Track
Mike Hill, Free State High, Baseball

2002
Patty Coffey, Southwest Junior High, Girls’ Track
Stan Frantz, West Junior High, Boys’ Baseball & Track
Jon Renberger, Free State High, Girls' Tennis
Chris Davis, Lawrence High, Boys’ Basketball